PMS vs CMYK: which one does your shop need?
Customers send us logos in RGB, ask for vector files, and expect them to print. Then the press operator gets the file and asks the question that should have been asked when you order: "Do you want PMS or CMYK?" Here is the answer, and the math behind it.
The short answer
Spot color (PMS) for jobs with fewer than 6 colors, or any time color accuracy matters more than photographic detail. CMYK process for full-color photography, gradients, or when budget rules out spot inks. Most apparel and sign jobs are PMS. Most marketing collateral is CMYK.
Why spot color exists
A PMS spot color is a pre-mixed ink — Pantone 354 C is one specific recipe of pigments that produces one specific green. Your press operator pulls the can off the shelf and prints with it directly. The color you see is the color that prints, every time, on every substrate.
Why CMYK exists
CMYK process builds simulate colors by overlaying tiny dots of cyan, magenta, yellow, and black. A "green" becomes a halftone pattern that fools the eye. You can reproduce thousands of colors with just four inks, but every color is an approximation — and the approximation changes with substrate, press condition, and humidity.
When PMS wins
Tight brand colors. Logos with flat color fields. Embroidery (one thread per color). Vinyl. Anything where the same logo gets printed on a hundred different items and needs to match across all of them. PMS gives you reproducibility; CMYK gives you variability.
When CMYK wins
Photography. Gradients. Posters with 50+ colors. Anything where you would need 8+ spot inks to reproduce — at which point CMYK is cheaper, faster, and only marginally less accurate. CMYK also wins when you do not control the press: most digital and web-to-print services run CMYK only.
What we do at VectorWiz
We default to PMS Solid Coated for sign shop, screen-print, and embroidery jobs. We default to CMYK process for general illustration and digital-print work. Either way, we ask at order time — and we call out the exact spec on every layer. See screen printing →
Related articles
Drawn by hand. Built for production.
Instant pricing, no commitment. Production-correct vectors in your inbox in 24.